Download Causation, Evidence, and Inference by Julian Reiss PDF

By Julian Reiss

In this publication, Reiss argues in desire of a good healthy among proof, notion and goal in our causal investigations within the sciences. there's no doubt that the sciences hire an enormous array of recommendations to handle causal questions comparable to managed experiments, randomized trials, statistical and econometric instruments, causal modeling and concept experiments. yet how do those diversified equipment relate to one another and to the causal inquiry handy? Reiss argues that there's no "gold normal" in settling causal matters opposed to which different equipment might be measured. quite, many of the equipment of inference are typically reliable purely relative to sure interpretations of the be aware "cause", and every interpretation, in flip, is helping to deal with a few salient objective (prediction, rationalization or coverage research) yet no longer others. the most aim of this publication is to discover the metaphysical and methodological effects of this view within the context of various circumstances reviews from the traditional and social sciences.

Show description

Read Online or Download Causation, Evidence, and Inference PDF

Best metaphysics books

Causation and Laws of Nature (Routledge Studies in Contemporary Philosophy)

This is often the 1st English translation of Causalite´ et Lois de los angeles Nature, and is a vital contribution to the speculation of causation. Max Kistler reconstructs a unified idea of causation that's basic adequate to appropriately take care of either straight forward actual procedures, and the macroscopic point of phenomena we stumble upon in daily life.

Efficient Causation: A History

Causation is now in most cases alleged to contain a succession that instantiates a few law-like regularity. effective Causation: A background examines how our sleek inspiration built from a truly assorted realizing of effective causation. This quantity starts with Aristotle's preliminary perception of effective causation, after which considers the adjustments and reconsiderations of this perception in overdue antiquity, medieval and sleek philosophy, finishing with modern money owed of causation.

The Cosmos of Duty: Henry Sidgwick's Methods of Ethics

Roger Crisp offers a complete examine of Henry Sidgwick's The equipment of Ethics, a landmark paintings first released in 1874. Crisp argues that Sidgwick is essentially correct approximately many vital concerns in ethical philosophy: the metaphysics and epistemology of ethics, consequentialism, hedonism approximately health, and the burden to accept to self-interest.

Cosmos and Logos : studies in Greek philosophy

The six stories comprising this quantity take care of a few primary matters in early Greek concept: cosmic assessment in Anaximander, the idea of opposites from the Pre-Socratics to Plato and Aristotle, inspiration experimentation in Pre-Socratic suggestion, the origins of Greek Skepticism one of the Sophisists, the prehistory of "Buridan's Ass" hypothesis, and the position of esthesis in Aristotle's idea of technological know-how.

Additional resources for Causation, Evidence, and Inference

Sample text

Moreover, background ‘theory’ is never strong enough to entail, together with the evidence, an instance of the generalization. Here ‘theory’ would refer to all the background knowledge necessary to ensure that the evidence (such as ‘Peter’s cough stopped after taking the medicine’) entails the instance of the hypothesis (‘Peter’s cough was relieved by the medicine’). This would mean we have made sure that there exists no other reason for which Peter’s cough may disappear except the medicine. 9 I should mention that there is an approach in econometrics that seems to be represented well with Glymour’s bootstrapping method: the structural, or Cowles Commission, approach.

Moreover, to avoid counterexamples, theories that events, event-types, or contrasts as causally related demand that the causally related events be independent in order to avoid counterexamples. Again, natural language is more flexible than that. My slamming of the door caused the door to be shut. The slamming and the shutting are not independent events, however. The inferentialist theory allows the analysis of the meaning of causal claims without forcing the latter into the ‘C causes E’ (or ‘C-rather-than-C´ causes E-rather-than-E´’) straightjacket.

But it is not precisely what I€will argue in the chapters that follow. I€will instead focus on the meaning of causal claims and argue that their meaning is given by certain inferential relations. The reason is simply that, for the purposes of this book, I€do not want to commit to an anti-realism about causal relations that would be implied by a position according to which causal relations are nothing but certain kinds of inferential relations. While I’d be inclined to think that anti-realism is true, for now I’ll leave open the possibility that causal claims can, at least sometimes, correctly describe the causal relations in the world.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.63 of 5 – based on 9 votes